The difficulties that the European country went by in the First World War and the colonization of land in America are seen still today, like the lack of male people, because most of them died in the war or economic instability that is seen today. Both of the poems relate to events that happened in the world, but in really different times.
“The soldier” involves the concern of the British people because of the world war. The poem tells about a soldier who is really patriotic and dedicates his last words to his motherland, England, and says that his actions will be forever remembered by the future generations. It’s important to note that the author died a year after he made this poem, probably because of the war, which makes it more ironic.
Jamaica gained his independence in 1962, now being a protectorate of the British colonies, supposedly not being under the control of Britain. The poem tries to portrait the situation of the Africans and Jamaicans that immigrated to the British colonies, and how they were trying to strive for better lives in there. The author talks about a “colonization in reverse” which might mean that Jamaicans are now conquering Great Britain. This is just as an aspirational thought, because that never really happened, and will never happen, for example, Mexico have not conquered Texas just because a lot of Mexican immigrants live there.
“The soldier” poem talks with a little but of rhythm accompanied with a rhetorical way of saying the things, for example He says things that relates to loving someone, but he’s talking all about England instead of a woman. He believes so much in England that he thinks that there is an “English heaven”. In the “colonization in reverse” it talks all about rhetorical elements, for example the thoughts of the author that Jamaica would get bigger and more powerful than the British colonies, only just because they achieved their independence. This also talks about ignorance, because she would not probably know the measurement of the situation in what she’s in.
The tone used in “colonization in reverse” is like the one which might me be used locally with friends or neighbors, which is a pretty strange way of talking, more like another language, like the Black English. In “the soldier” the language is clear enough to understand the philosophical elements and know what the author is saying. The Great Britain idioms didn’t seem to vary a lot from the ones used in the United States in that time, but now we can see the difference in words like gentleness, we now use kindness.
The poems talk about weird things that could be interpreted as other things such as salvation in this part of the “colonization in reverse” poem:
“Jane says de dole is not too bad
Because dey payin she
Two pounds a week fe seek a job
dat suit her dignity.”
In this situation, the author believes that with a work, the people can be saved with all the suffering that they have been going though, and of course working is not all the things needed to succeed. We also can say that in that time, everyone in Jamaica was still ignorant, as we can see in the writing and the pronunciation of things, also in the grammar it can be noted that.
In the situation in “the solider” it can be interpreted that the author sees himself in the battlefield, because he is involved directly in the war. Here’s an example to show it:
“If I should die, think only this of me:
That there's some corner of a foreign field
That is forever England. There shall be
In that rich earth a richer dust concealed;”
In conclusion, I say that both of the texts were made on inspirational times, which lead to different opinions and thoughts about their own situation, but they differ enormously in the way that hey interpret and say the things; I one side, the author of “the soldier” believes entirely that the British colonies are the most powerful country in the world, which is a fact, but the author of “colonization in reverse” relies entirely in things that she wants to happen in the future, and she believes that will really happen.
Word count: 715